The New York Times music critic, Anthony Tommasini, came up a with a list of the 10 greatest composers. This is not supposed to be just a list of his personal favorites, but a reasoned attempt to rank composers not only by their inspiration but also according to other criteria such as their influence on classical music. Though many people thought the exercise silly, many more felt compelled to participate in it, voting, commenting and submitting their preferences. I was one of them.
Here is the list that Tommasini came up with:
1. Bach
2. Beethoven
3. Mozart
4. Schubert
5. Debussy
6. Stravinsky
7. Brahms
8. Verdi
9. Wagner
10. Bartok
Surprisingly, it would seem most people who participated in this exercise are in broad agreement about most names. I certainly could subscribe at least to eight of them.
About the first three, the only argument would probably be the order in which they should appear. After giving much thought to the subject, I would probably place Mozart first, followed by Beethoven and then Bach.
Should Schubert come in fourth? There is no doubt he was a great composer but he died young, he had a narrow range and was at his best only in chamber music and song cycles. So I would probably relegate him to a lower rank.
One objection I have to this list is the presence of Debussy at number 5. Don't get me wrong, I love Debussy, but is not Stravinsky a much greater composer, with a much broader range? And what about the other 19th century titans? Debussy may have been very influential but he would probably not make my list.
Next comes Stravinsky. Here the only question is whether he should placed higher, since to my mind he is undoubtedly the greatest XXth century composer.
In my opinion, Brahms deserves to make it, though he is not to everybody's taste. But ahead of Verdi and Wagner? I am not sure...
Verdi and Wagner, no question they should be in.
As for Bela Bartok, I have strong reservations. Apart from personal tastes, his music does not seem to be aging well. It now sounds ponderous and overwrought. But I admit this opinion may be founded more on prejudice than on knowledge.
Who is left out? First and foremost, Chopin. He should definitely be in. I would also probably make cases could for Haendel, Haydn, Schumann, and Puccini. I also saw a lot of comments arguing in favor of Mahler and Tchaikovsky, but these two, great as they may be, would not make my list. Some also argued for Britten, a few for Alban Berg...All things considered, I think Chopin should certainly replace Bartok and probably Debussy should make way for Haendel, though it is heartbreaking to leave Haydn, Schumann or Puccini out (my personal favorite among the three being Schumann).
And finally, shouldn't one spare a thought also for Johan Strauss Jr?
This list raises a larger point: given the heavy presence of XIXth century composers and German ones to boot, would it be fair to conclude that so-called classical music is time and place specific? An art that reached its apogee in the germanic speaking lands of Central Europe between, say, 1780 and 1910? I would probably answer yes. "Classical music" is not dead and it is still too early to have a good perspective on the XXth century. But my bet is that, with historical perspective, the XXth will be seen as the century of popular music, an american or anglo-saxon century, in which jazz and rock will rank as high as classical music, and names such as Miles Davies and The Beatles will be as much part of the cannon as the great composers of the past.
Monday, January 24, 2011
Wednesday, January 12, 2011
Janacek

The Gulbenkian Foundation mounted a superb production of Janacek's last opera, "From the House of Dead", first performed in 1930, after the Czech composer's death. A staged concert performance, with video projection, a great cast and musical direction by the finnish conductor Esa-Pekka Salonen, this show revealed a great work, taut, relentless, dramatic, which certainly places Janacek in the canon of XXth century classical music. In Lisbon, January 6 and 7th 2011.
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
Friday, December 10, 2010
Roll Over Beethoven
To promote the arrival of The Beatles, I Tunes is posting a video of their first live show in America (1964, Washington D.C.) No wonder the teenagers were hysterical, crying and screaming at the top of their heads: The Beatles were hot and rock was the wave of the future. Watching this film, 45 years later, one still feels the energy rush, the blood flowing to the head, a feeling of happiness, a great positive discharge of adolescent agression.
Thursday, November 18, 2010
Keith Richard's Life (on drugs)
Keith Richard's memoirs are highly entertaining. One thing is clear: apart from music, there is nothing he likes better than drugs. His consumption is staggering: the carefully controlled doses of smack are mixed with gargantuan cocaine sniffs (the purest stuff, he emphasizes), a huge variety of pills (Tuinals, etc...) liberal doses of Jack Daniels, the whole taking place in a huge cloud of hash and spiff, not counting of course the cigarettes always dangling from his mouth and the occasional acid trip. How is this man alive? The music kept him going, the huge high of being on stage and playing these deeply satisfying, addictive, riffs which he describes in loving detail. The music: "what you are looking for is where the sounds just melt into one another and you've got that beat behind it, and the rest of it just has to squirm and roll its way through. What you are looking for is power and force - without volume". (Above, the Stones in their prime, blasting their way through Bitch in Australia:) For him "the chicks" come fourth or fifth. Had she not been intent on outdoing Keith on drug taking and outrageous behaviour, he would still be married to Anita Pallenberg, that "tough bitch". The book reads as if Richards just decided to let go and tell his life in a fit of absentmindness, which he now probably (but secretly) regrets.
Labels:
Bitch,
Keith Richards,
Rock,
The Rolling Stones
Wednesday, November 10, 2010
A Religiosa Portuguesa

"A Religiosa Portuguesa", with its postcard perfect photography of Lisbon, its tongue in cheek hieratic dialogues, its strange mix of allusions to portuguese mythology, its superb performances of fado by Camané and Aldina Duarte, is cool, entrancing, almost moving at times. It sometimes feels like a Manuel de Oliveira movie made good, a kind of savant reinterpretation of the slow ponderous style of portuguese art cinema, enlivened by dry wit, songs, mystery and just the right amount of storytelling. Eugene Green makes it come aaaliiiive, like that, in slow motion.
Thursday, November 4, 2010
Stunning
Browsing through a back issue of Vogue at the doctor, I stumbled upon an article about British photographer Sam Taylor-Wood: her John Lennon biopic "Nowhere Boy" is about to be released in Spain; she is married to the actor who plays Lennon, 23 years her junior; they just had a child, her third; she has survived two cancers, including a full mastectomy. I felt an immediate electric kinship and could not wait until I checked her out on the internet. So there she is, on these stunning series of photographs, the Bram Stocker Chair series. Stunning.
Saturday, October 9, 2010
Why is Literature Important?
"Time that is intolerant
Of the brave and the innocent,
And indifferent in a week
To a beautiful physique,
Worships language and forgives
Everyone by whom it lives;
Pardons cowardice, conceit
Lays its honours at their feet."
W.H.Auden
"In Memory of W.B. Yeats (d. Jan 1939)
Friday, October 8, 2010
Mario Vargas Llosa

For once, everyone agrees. Vargas Llosa's Nobel prize is richly deserved. He is supremely accomplished as a novelist, literary critic and journalist. He is respected, well liked, generous to a fault to his fellow writers. His politics may not be to everyone's liking, but at least he stays clear of compromising friendships with the likes of Fidel Castro. He is is every sense a cosmopolitan writer. Strictly wedded to the realist novel, as practiced by the great XIXth century masters - Tolstoy, Balzac, Flaubert, whom he worships - he is equally at home in Peru, in Paris or in the Congo, the scene of his latest novel, due in November. He writes a beautiful, limpid, compelling spanish. Once one starts reading, the precision and the musicality of his style, as well as his impeccable storytelling technique rarely fail to carry one through to the end. A literary genius? Perhaps not. But certainly a great writer and a highly respectable man.
Sunday, August 1, 2010
Israeli novelists

On the strength of "The Liberated Bride", superbly translated into english, I would guess A. B. Yehoshua may be the best Israeli novelist on the market. Yes, better than Amos Oz - notwithstanding his wonderful memoir, "Tales of Love and Darkness" - not to mention David Grossman - whom I do not really know - or Aharon Appelfeld - who seems to write more about Europe than Israel. The hero of the book, Rivlin, is a fumbling orientalist deeply in love with his wife, a district court judge in Haifa. I do not recall a funnier, more perceptive account of a happy marriage as Yehoshua provides in this book. His dialogue is masterful, with a magnificent ability to convey subtle changes of mood and tone. Rivlin, the professor, is obsessed with piercing the secret of his son's divorce. This search drives the plot, but the book is really about relations between arabs and jews, love and marriage, life in the Holy Land circa 1999 and slight episodes of a humdrum middle class life which Yehoshua manages to capture through small details and to describe with a light touch and a great comical gift. Episode by episode, he manages to hold the reader's attention to a story which seems to be nothing at all. I wonder what an arab reader would make of his take on the arabs - mostly Israeli arabs, fluent in Hebrew. Would they find it patronizing or, on the contrary, humane?
Labels:
A.B. Yehoshua,
Aharon Appelfeld,
Amos Oz,
David Grossman,
Israel,
Literature
Sunday, June 27, 2010
The status of contemporary art
The buzz generated by contemporary art in the first decade of the XXIst century sometimes reminds me of the excitement generated by pop music in the 1960's. Something new is in the air — some new cultural trend, some new mass phenomenom of which everybody wants to be part of. Maybe what has happened is that there has been a profound change in the status of contemporary art: no longer an elitist pursuit, it has become part of popular culture. Just as happened with "classical" music, the cannon desintegrated — in the case of art, this desintegration meant the end of the idea of a "vanguard". In its place appeared a bewildering eclecticism, in which it is difficult, maybe even impossible, to distinguish"high" and "low" forms of art. Even though artistic schools produce every year an ever greater quantity of artists, it is no longer necessary to master every detail of the craft to qualify as an artist. You can be a visual artist without knowing how to draw, just as you can play lead guitar in a rock n' roll band without knowing how to read music.
Thursday, June 24, 2010
Pietro Citati

Pietro Citati is a reader. He reads for us, voratiously, lovingly, attentively, and then recreates, in romantic and fluid prose, the great literary masterpieces of the western tradition, and the minor half forgotten pieces, the lives and temperament of their heroic authors, the cultural atmosphere in which they worked, their manias, obsessions and visions. He guides us through this labyrinth of words, through this mountain of pages, through this perpetually expanding literary universe and its innumerable bright stars: Daniel Defoe, Goethe, Jane Austen, Thomas De Quincey, Balzac, Alexandre Dumas, Flaubert, Tolstoy, Manzoni, Dickens, Dostoievsky, Poe, Stevenson, Henry James, Proust, Kafka, Fitzgerald... As we read on, we renew old loves, we reacquaint ourselves with friends we hadn't heard of in years and we discover infinite new reading possibilities. These are all the more alluring as most will never be more than that...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)